Why does a sliver of fact make them nervous
whether the topic is God, economics,
psychoanalysis, or Superman comics?
This “pewed" attitude leaves you no room to grow.
Reply (maybe) too serious from GOOGLE AI:
The phenomenon you're describing—the imperviousness of believers and the anxiety triggered by contradictory facts—is a well-documented aspect of human psychology. It's less about the specific belief (whether religious, economic, or pop culture-based) and more about how the brain processes information that threatens a core, established worldview.
Here are the key psychological reasons that explain this reaction.
1. Cognitive dissonance
Cognitive dissonance is the mental discomfort we feel when our beliefs, attitudes, and behaviors are in conflict. To escape this discomfort, people tend to do one of three things:
Change their belief to match the new information (the most difficult option for deeply held beliefs).
Justify or rationalize their existing belief.
Reject or ignore the new, conflicting information.
Rejecting the new information is often the path of least resistance because it allows us to avoid the mental work and anxiety of overhauling our worldview.
2. Confirmation bias
This is the tendency to favor information that confirms our existing beliefs while disregarding or actively avoiding contradictory evidence. Instead of seeking an objective truth, we search for sources that validate what we already think and reject any information that doesn't align with our views. In a world of social media, this effect is magnified by "filter bubbles" that isolate us from opposing perspectives.
3. Identity and threat
Our core beliefs are often intertwined with our personal identity. When a belief is challenged, it can feel like a direct attack on our sense of self, triggering a fight-or-flight response. This causes our brain to release hormones like cortisol and adrenaline, which can hijack our reasoning and logic and make it difficult to hear other viewpoints. The desire to defend our identity can make us double down on our beliefs, even when they're proven wrong.
4. Fear of the unknown
Humans are wired to seek stability and predictability. Uncertainty, the opposite of certainty, activates the same stress pathways in the brain as a physical threat. When confronted with information that erodes a cherished belief, we face an uncertain future where our old mental shortcuts no longer work. For many people, this is a terrifying and deeply unsettling state, making them cling to the familiar certainty of their original belief.
5. Effort justification
When we invest significant time, emotion, and energy into a particular idea or belief, we become psychologically invested in its truth. This is known as effort justification. The more we've dedicated to a belief, the more difficult it is to let go. Changing our mind would mean acknowledging that the initial investment was, at least in part, a waste. This is why a person who has dedicated their entire life to a belief system will have a much harder time abandoning it than a casual follower.
6. Growth is uncomfortable
Your final line, "certitude leaves no room to grow,"* is a central theme in psychological and philosophical thought. The process of questioning deeply held beliefs and embracing uncertainty is crucial for growth, but it is also profoundly uncomfortable. It forces us to confront our fears and admit the limits of our knowledge. In contrast, remaining impervious allows a person to avoid this difficult work by clinging to the security of their existing belief system.
AI responses may include mistakes.
—————
*Changed to “This “pewed" attitude leaves you no room to grow.” after AI critique.
